Development of High performance Cadmium free Cu-chalcopyrite thin film solar cells with CBD-Zn(S,O) buffer layer

Prof. Ahmed Ennaoui
Chairman of the Scientific Council – IRESEN

By Prof. Ahmed Ennaoui, Chairman of the Scientific Council, Institut de Recherche en Energie Solaire et Energies Nouvelles (IRESEN), Rabat, Morocco.
Former head of physical Chemistry group at Helmholtz Zentrum Berlin für Materialien und Energie, Lise-Meitner-Campus, Hahn-Meitner-Platz 1, 14109 Berlin, Germany.
One of the most promising classes of materials for thin-film photovoltaic devices is the Cupper chalcopyrite quaternary chalcogenides known with the general formula Cu(InxGa1-x)(SySe1-y)2 or CIGSS. The best solar devices are fabricated with cadmium sulfide (CdS) buffer layer between the p-doped CIGSS absorber and i-ZnO/n+-ZnO window bilayer prepared by solution growth technique known as chemical bath deposition. Solar cells with record efficiency of 22.6% using lab-sized (0.5 square centimetre) was obtained, however to avoid Cadmium as a heavy metal compound in the final modules, other buffer layers have been tested as alternative to CdS such as Zn(S,O) and similar record efficiency up to 22.9% on a 1cm² cell was published recently [1]. The solution chemistry of the CBD process plays a crucial role. For the preparation of Zn(S,O), the reaction paths involving aqueous solution containing zinc sulfate, ZnSO4, ammonia NH3, and thiourea [(NH2)2CS)] depend critically on the equilibrium concentration of free hydrated Zn2+ versus that of Zn2+ complexes with the complexing agents present in the solution, namely, OH, NH3, and thiourea. Upon heating, thiourea decomposes to release S2- ions, which can combine with free Zn2+ at the surface of the absorber to form ZnS through heterogeneous process. However, due to the high concentration of OH in the alkaline solution, the formation of turbid Zn(OH)2 from Zn2+ and OH is a competing reaction, so that the final layer can best be described as a mixture of ZnS and Zn(OH)2. Furthermore, due to the predominant presence of Zn complexes rather than free Zn2+, formation rate of ZnO is low even in alkaline solution, which is a prerequisite for ZnS formation. We observed the best Zn(S,O) layers in terms of device efficiency by first adding thiourea to an aqueous solution of ZnSO4, heating this mixture up to 80°C, and then adding ammonia (referred as here as CBD-T). The standard process obtained by combining ZnSO4 with ammonia first and then adding thiourea (referred here as CBD-N) leads to inferior devices. This is surprising, because one would expect the product of reversible complex formation between Zn2+ and the ligands ammonia and thiourea to depend only on the heat of formation of the respective complex and not on the order of adding the chemicals. For profound understanding, on the role of the two complexes CBD-T and CBD-N, we performed real time soft X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) to probe chemical reactions by measuring the L-edge of Zn species in solution under ambient conditions in situ during the CBD and annealing processes [2]. We showed that CBD-T and CBD-N processes lead to completely different zinc precursor complexes in solution, despite identical concentrations of starting materials. Obviously the Zn-S=C complex which forms in the CBD-T exhibits ligand-to-metal electron transfer and metal-to ligand back-donation. This back-donation is missing in the CBD-N process, in which the more stable zinc–ammonia complex is formed and no Zn–S interaction takes place. Based on this new type of complexation which results in homogeneous and compact nanocrystalline bilayers ZnS/Zn(S,O), the process is patented [3]. To reduce high density of acceptor-like defects at CIGS/Zn(S,O) interfaces a post annealing step is required to passivates the defects via interdiffusion and thus improves the cell performance. In this talk we review our work on Cd-free CIGSSe solar cells performed at Helmholtz-Zentrum Berlin für Materialien und Energie (HZB) in joint effort with several industry partners. Solar cell efficiency above 16% was obtained with Zn(S,O)/CIGSSe based solar cell after post annealing in air for lab scale. We successfully up-scaled the CBD-Zn(S,O) process from laboratory scale (0.5 cm² single cell devices) to large area Cd-free solar modules (60cm x 120cm) with efficiency closed to 13%. We will highlight the fundamental understanding of CBD-Zn(S,O) on Cu(In,Ga)(S,Se)2 (CIGSSe) and Cu(In,Ga)Se2 (CIGSe) to form high performance solar cells and modules [4].

[1] Solar Cell Efficiency Tables (Version 51), Progress in Photovoltaics: Research and Applications 2018.
[2] ChemPhysChem (2009), vol.10, pp.532-535
[3] US Patent 7.704,863 B2 Method of the application of zinc sulfide buffer layer on a semiconductor substrate
[4] Special issue: Prog. Photovolt: Res. Appl. vol. 18 (2010) pp. 411–433

Most of this work was achieved at HZB, “Helmholtz Zentrum Berlin für Materialien und Energie and supported partly by the European Commission within the framework of several projects (CHEETAH, ATHLET, NEBULES, CISLINE, Joules II)) and by the “Bundesministerium für Bildung und Forschung (BMBF)”. I especially acknowledge all industry partners for their supply of the samples, and I am grateful to my former Ph.D. students, Post-Doc, and all my colleagues at the department of heterogeneous material systems either for their technical assistance or for critical discussions.


Ahmed Ennaoui studied physics and chemistry and obtained his master and doctoral degree in solid-state electronics from the University of Bourgogne, France.  He moved to Germany and conducted research for his habilitation (1983-1987) with Prof. Helmut Tributsch in the department “Abteilung Solare Energetik und Materialforschung” at the Hahn Meitner Institute (HMI), Berlin, Germany. After obtaining his habilitation (summa cum laude) for his research on novel earth-abundant and non-toxic materials (Iron Disulfide, Pyrite) for solar energy conversion, he served as Professor of physics at the University Mohamed V. He moved back to Germany and worked as senior scientist at the HMI, while maintaining strong contact with Moroccan universities.  He was appointed head of a research group at Helmholtz-Zentrum Berlin (HZB) “the former HMI” and explored in his group novel alternative materials for solar energy conversion. He received different grant projects financed by the European commission and the German Federal Ministry of Education and conducted successful feasibility studies financed by the industry (Siemens/Shell-Solar/Avancis, Solibro, Bosch, Atotech). All his projects are targeting thin Film solar cells and new concept, from planar films to nanostructures. He served as member of Qatar Foundation (2015-2017) with a position of joint Professor at Hamad Bin Khalifa University (HBKU) and as Research Director of Solar Energy group at Qatar Environmental and Energy Research Institute (QEERI). At QEERI he was conducting research, managing research groups, recruiting top talents. He established track record, building partnerships with industry and academia at QEERI/HBKU during the period from January 2015 to May 2017 and the management of scientists at QEERI ‘s solar test facilities (STF with: ~200 kW). He contributed to the development of PV soiling solution, improving O&M of the infrastructure at the STF. At QEERI he proposed also a relevant low CAPEX manufacturing Thin Film PV technology to reduce the cost per watt peak of solar modules through building of a base line for inkjet printing as a precision deposition technology for flexible PV. He designed syllabus for HBKU and taught several seminar on Solar Photovoltaic Technology for graduate students. Actually Prof. Ahmed Ennaoui serves as president of the Scientific Council of IRESEN, the Moroccan Solar Energy Research Institute, deeply engaged at for the establishment of mechanisms to support and reinforce R&D on renewable energy. Ahmed Ennaoui has deep expertise in processing materials and devices for solar energy conversion and thin film chalcogenide solar cells. He is author and co-author of more than 200 peer-reviewed journal articles, numerous conference contributions, five special issues and granted several patents, his published work on pyrite FeS<sub>2</sub>, 2D layered materials, kesterite, cadmium free chalcopyrite solar cells, DSSC solar cells has being recognized with h-index 41. He is permanent member of the Editorial Board of Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells, reviewer for several top scientific journals, member of International Solar Energy Society (ISES), member of IEEE and chair of the scientific-technical committee for the International Renewable and Sustainable Energy Conference (IRSEC). During his career he supervised more than 40 completed thesis and ca. 15 Postdoctoral have worked in his group.

Dr. Luis Miguel MirandaINESCTEC, Portugal

Validating Microgrids Islanding and Black Start Procedures in a Laboratorial Environment

By Dr. Luís Miguel Miranda, INESCTEC, Portugal. Microgrids (MG) are extremely flexible low voltage (LV) networks capable of operating interconnected with ...

Read More

Prof. Raymond AdomaitisUniversity of Maryland, USA

Engineering and Automation Perspectives of Team Maryland in the 2017 US Solar Decathlon

By Prof. Raymond Adomaitis, University of Maryland, USA. The engineering design of reACT (resilient Adaptive Climate Technology) was driven by a ...

Read More

Dr. Samuel Magorrian
National Graphene Institute in Manchester, UK

Optoelectronics of two - dimensional post - transition metal chalcogenides

By Dr. Samuel Magorrian, National Graphene Institute in Manchester, UK We present the analysis of electronic band structure of InSe and ...

Read More

Dr. Giacomo-Giorgi
University of Perugia, Italy

Excitons in 3D Pb-free Bulk and in Mixed 3D/2D Hybrid Perovskites: Optical Signatures and Spatial Localization

By Dr. Giacomo-Giorgi, University of Perugia, Italy. Organic-Inorganic Halide Perovskites (OIHPs) are undoubtedly playing the key role in the realm of ...

Read More

Dr. Ralf Hunger
Head of Process Integration
Solibro Hi-tech GmbH

Solibro CIGS Technology – from small cell CIGS devices to industrial manufacturing in a global production

By Dr. Ralf Hunger, Head of Process Integration, Solibro Hi-tech GmbH, Germany. Solibro is an international group of research, engineering, and ...

Read More

Dr. Jie XiaoPacific Northwest national laboratory & University of Arkansas, USA

Understanding Lithium Metal Failure Mechanism in Realistic High-Energy Pouch Cells

By Dr. Jie Xiao, Pacific Northwest national laboratory & University of Arkansas, USA To significantly boost the energy of the state-of-art ...

Read More

Prof. Bulent Akinoglu Middle East Technical University, Ankara, Turkey

Long and short term PV module and array performance calculations and feasibility studies

By Prof. Bulent Akinoglu, Middle East Technical University, Ankara, Turkey. While solar photovoltaic (PV) R/D is heavily continuing, worldwide solar power ...

Read More

Dr Lukas Sigrist

Operation of Isolated Power Systems under High Shares of Renewables

By Dr Lukas Sigrist, Universidad Pontificia Comillas, Spain. The increasing penetration of large shares of renewable energy resources allows reducing ...

Read More

Prof. Masataka Nagaoka/b>Nagoya University, Japan

Microscopic Additive Effect on SEI Film Formation in Sodium-Ion Batteries: A Computational Chemical Study based on Red Moon Methodology

By Prof. Masataka Nagaoka, Nagoya University, Japan. Recently, we have developed a new efficient hybrid Monte Carlo (MC)/molecular dynamics (MD) reaction ...

Read More

Mr. Jose Benlloch FernandezMayor of  Vila-real City, Spain

Support for innovation from the Local Government: the example of Valencian cities network for innovation

By Mr. Jose Benlloch Fernandez, Mayor of Vila-real City, Spain. For the most advanced modern societies, the promotion of knowledge is ...

Read More

Dr. Maria Wall Lund University, Sweden

Towards zero-energy buildings and neighborhoods

By Dr Maria Wall, Associate Prof., Division of Energy and Building Design, Lund University, Sweden. The presentation will cover topics as: - ...

Read More

Prof.  João A. Peças Lopes
Porto University, Portugal

Use of Microgrids and DERs for black start and islanding operation

By Prof. Joao Peças Lopes, Porto University, Portugal. Microgrids can be considered as the building block of a SmartGrid. These networks ...

Read More

Dr Teodor Todorov 
IBM, Watson Research Center, Yorktown Heights, USA

Progress and Challenges in High-efficiency Kesterite Solar Cells

By Dr. Teodor Todorov, IBM T. J. Watson Research Center, Yorktown Heights, USA. Thin-film multinary chalcogenide absorbers have numerous attractive properties ...

Read More

Dr. Ivan GordonSilicon PV group, imec, Belgium.

Towards the ultimate Silicon solar cell and module

By Dr. Ivan Gordon, Silicon PV group, imec, Belgium. In this presentation, the current status and the main R&D challenges of ...

Read More

Strategies for hole transporting layer for efficient and stable perovskite solar cells

By Dr Samrana Kazim, BCMaterials-Basque Center for Materials, Applications and Nanostructures, Leioa, Spain. Hybrid organic-inorganic perovskite solar cells (PSCs) have shown ...

Read More

Prof. Juan Bautista Carda Castelló,Universitat Jaume I, Spain

The quest for new functional applications of environmentally friendly ceramic tiles in the context of a circular economy

Prof. Juan Bautista Carda Castelló, Universitat Jaume I, Spain The Spanish industry of ceramic tiles manufacturing is mainly concentrated in Castelló, ...

Read More

Dr. Edgardo Saucedo
IREC, Spain

Kesterite Thin Film Photovoltaics: Review on Cationic and Anionic Substitution for High Efficiency Solar Cells

By Dr. Edgardo Saucedo, Catalonia Institute for Energy Research (IREC), Barcelona, Spain. The so called kesterite (Cu2ZnSn(S,Se)4 – CZTSSe; Cu2ZnSnS4 – ...

Read More

Dr. Karim Zaghib Director at Hydro-Québec, Canada

Safe Li-ion Batteries and Beyond for Energy Storage and EVs

By Dr. Karim Zaghib, Director at Hydro-Québec, Canada. We report a Li-ion battery that can be charged within few minutes, passes ...

Read More

Prof. Teofilo Rojo CIC Energigune, Spain

Recent advances, current challenges and future trends on sodium-ion batteries.

By Prof. Teófilo ROJO 1. Department of Inorganic Chemistry. Faculty of Science and Technology. University of the Basque Country (UPV/EHU), ...

Read More

Prof. Ahmed EnnaouiChairman of the Scientific Council - IRESEN

Development of High performance Cadmium free Cu-chalcopyrite thin film solar cells with CBD-Zn(S,O) buffer layer

By Prof. Ahmed Ennaoui, Chairman of the Scientific Council, Institut de Recherche en Energie Solaire et Energies Nouvelles (IRESEN), Rabat, ...

Read More

Dr. Saad Baradiy, iproplan® Planungsgesellschaft mbH, Germany.

Energy Efficiency and using of Renewable Energy In the field of tension between prosperity, environmental protection, resource conservation and economical aspects

By Dr. Saad Baradiy, iproplan® Planungsgesellschaft mbH, Germany. The author will explain the state of the art in Germany with current ...

Read More

Prof. Moncef KrartiUniversity of Colorado, USA

Benefits of Scale-up Building Energy Efficiency Programs

By Prof. Moncef Krarti, University of Colorado, USA. The presentation introduces a new concept of energy productivity that accounts for both ...

Read More

Ismael Saadoune

Ismael Saadoune

Prof. Ismael Saadoune FST, Cadi Ayyad University, Marrakech, Morocco Prof. Ismael Saadoune, FST, Cadi Ayyad University, Marrakech, Morocco. Biography Ismael SAADOUNE, Full Professor in the ...

Read More

Khalil Amine

Khalil Amine

By Dr. Khalil Amine, distinguished Fellow and manager of the Advanced Lithium Battery Technology program at Argonne National Laboratory, IL, ...

Read More

Prof. Dieter Meissner

Crystalsol's Printed Single Crystalline Kesterite Photovoltaic Modules

By Prof. Dieter Meissner, Tallinn University of Technology, Estonia. Crystalsol, a spin-out company of Tallinn University of Technology, has developed a ...

Read More

Prof. Abdelkader Kara
University of Central Florida, USA

Interface Characteristics of 2D Organic Materials on Metal Surfaces

By Prof. Abdelkader Kara, University of Central Florida, USA. Organic materials are playing an increasing role in electronics and particularly in ...

Read More

Prof. Abdelilah Benyoussef
Moroccan Foundation for Advanced Science, Innovation and Research, Morocco

Abdelilah Benyoussef

Prof. Abdelilah Benyoussef, Moroccan Foundation for Advanced Science, Innovation and Research, Morocco. Prof. Abdelilah Benyoussef received his "Doctorat d’état" degree from ...

Read More

Hamid Oughaddou
Institut des Sciences Moléculaires d’Orsay, Université Paris-Sud,  France

New 2D materials: silicene and phosphorene

By Prof. Hamid Oughaddou, Institut des Sciences Moléculaires d’Orsay, Université Paris-Sud, France The remarkable properties of graphene stem from its two-dimensional ...

Read More

Structural Disorder in Kesterite-type Semiconductors

Structural Disorder in Kesterite-type Semiconductors

By Prof. Dr. Susan Schorr, Helmholtz-Zentrum Berlin, Germany. Kesterite-type compound semiconductors (Cu2ZnSnS4 – CZTS, Cu2ZnSnSe4 – CZTSe) are probably the most ...

Read More

Mohammad Khaja Nazeeruddin

Mohammad Khaja Nazeeruddin

Biography Prof. Mohammad K. Nazeeruddin current research at EPFL focuses on Dye Sensitized and Perovskite Solar Cells, CO2 reduction, Hydrogen production, ...

Read More

Dr Oliver Groning

Engineering of novel electronic materials by the atomically precise on-surface synthesis of graphene nanostructures

Dr. Oliver Gröning, Empa Materials Science and Technology, Dübendorf, Switzerland Graphene provides an ideal platform to create diverse electronic properties by ...

Read More

Prof. Clas PerssonUniversity of Oslo, Norway & KTH Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden

Copper-based chalcogenides for ultrathin inorganic solar cells

Emerging Cu-based materials are explored to benefit from the energetically high-lying Cu d-state in combination with low effective mass of ...

Read More

Prof. Ari Paavo Seitsonen
École Normale Supérieure, Paris, France

Computer modelling and design of two-dimensional materials beyond graphene

By Dr. Ari Paavo Seitsonen, Research Engineer at École Normale Supérieure, Paris, France. The continuous miniaturization, emergence of the practical realization ...

Read More

Prof. Ahmad ShahzadaBCMaterials, Bilbao, Spain

Perovskite solar cells: A paradigm shift in thin film photovoltaics research

By Prof. Shahzada Ahmad, Basque Center for Materials, Applications, and Nanostructures, Leioa, Spain. Perovskites solar cells (PSCs) have emerged as a ...

Read More

Special Issue


  • Ministry of Energy, Mines, and  Sustainable Development
  • L'economiste - daily newspaper
  • Energies Environnement Mag
  • Faculty of Science - Rabat
  • Mohammed V University
  • IEEE Morocco Section
  • University of Abdelmalek Essaadi
  • Solar Cluster
  • ISES - International Solar Energy Society
  • emi
  • giz
  • masen

Important dates

Late Submission Deadline October 10, 2018
Notification to authors October 22, 2018
Final version due November 08, 2018
Registration deadline November 08, 2018
IRSEC'18 Conference Dec., 5-8, 2018